- Success Criterion 1.2.2
- Conformance level A
Transcript Offered Instead of Required Synchronized Captions
1.2.2 — Captions (Prerecorded)
Scenario
Setting
A social media platform's settings menu
What’s wrong
Only a transcript provided when synchronized captions are required (transcript alone doesn't satisfy 1.2.2).
Example
<video src="/help/privacy-settings-walkthrough.mp4" controls></video>
<a href="/help/privacy-settings-transcript.pdf">Download transcript (PDF)</a> Why it matters
A deaf user trying to follow the privacy walkthrough has to pause the video, switch to a separate PDF, and manually match paragraphs to what's happening on screen.
How to test
Look for a caption track (CC) on the video: if only a separate transcript link is offered with no synchronized captions, it fails Level A.
How to fix
A transcript is a nice addition but doesn't satisfy 1.2.2 on its own; prerecorded video with audio needs synchronized captions.
<video src="/help/privacy-settings-walkthrough.mp4" controls>
<track kind="captions" src="/help/privacy-settings-walkthrough.vtt" srclang="en" label="English">
</video>
<a href="/help/privacy-settings-transcript.pdf">Download transcript (PDF)</a> Outcome
A deaf user follows each privacy toggle exactly as it's clicked, without flipping between two windows.
Who is affected
Deaf and hard-of-hearing users lose the ability to follow the video in real time, since a static transcript can't stay synced with what's currently on screen.
Learn more
- Understanding Understanding document (opens in a new tab)
Related scenarios
- Captions That Skip Dialogue or Important Sound Effects
- Video-as-Text-Alternative Never Labeled or Captioned
- Video With Extra Content the Captions Never Include
- Prerecorded Video Published With No Captions Whatsoever
- YouTube Auto-Captions Never Corrected for Accuracy
- Captions That Drift Out of Sync With the Audio